Methodological problems related to alcohol research among Turks and Moroccans living in the Netherlands: findings from semi-structured interviews
Author: Dotinga A, van den Eijnden RJ, Bosveld W, Garretsen HF
Source:
Ethnicity & Health, 9(2), 139-151.
OBJECTIVES: To identify factors related to alcohol use among Turks and Moroccans
living in the Netherlands. Furthermore, to reveal methodological problems related
to research among Turks and Moroccans in general and to alcohol research among
these groups in particular. DESIGN: Individual face-to-face interviews were
carried out with Dutch researchers (n = 9), Turkish and Moroccan (health)
practitioners working in the field with Turks (n = 4) or Moroccans (n = 2), and
members of the target population with a Turkish (n = 3) or a Moroccan background
(n = 2). Furthermore, focus-group interviews were held with Turkish women (n =
4), Turkish men (n = 3), Moroccan women (n = 4) and Moroccan men (n = 3) working
as health professionals. RESULTS: Alcohol use seems prevalent particularly among
second-generation Turks and Moroccans and is related to: upbringing, influence of
peer groups, integration and the degree in which Islamic rules are practised.
Written questionnaires seem more appropriate for second-generation Turks and
Moroccans, because they have fewer language problems and are more familiar with
Western bureaucratic society. However, both generations may prefer face-to-face
interviews since both groups fear that 'written' answers about the sensitive
subject 'alcohol use' may somehow become known among community members.
Similarly, an interviewer with a Dutch background may elicit more reliable
answers about alcohol use than an interviewer with a Turkish or Moroccan
background. CONCLUSION: In alcohol research special attention should be paid to
second-generation Turks and Moroccans. Although it is probably easier to conduct
alcohol studies in this group than in first-generation Turks and Moroccans,
quantitative research is needed to test the hypothesis that written
questionnaires elicit more reliable answers about alcohol use than face-to-face
interviews. Furthermore, the influence of ethnic matching on response and data
quality should be tested further.